Perfection Not Giants Problem
Thursday, December 27th, 2007Let me start by saying I hate the Giants and the Patriots. In fact, as much as I root against some teams here and there, this week’s Saturday night showdown features the only two teams I consistently and ferociously root to fail, week in and year out.
That being said, when Week 17 rolled out on the NFL calender a few months ago, I chuckled at how torn I would be when it came to who I would support in this game. But thanks to a Buffalo collapse (and consequent Giants clinch) last weekend, my decision is easy: fuck the Patriots, let’s go Big Blue; no qualms about it. So when it comes to the debate over what head coach Tom Coughlin should do, I am gung ho about him trotting his starting, most competitive team out there to try and derail (no chance) the Pats perfect season (dear god…)
BUT…
How the tits can he do that and justify his decision? There have been a myriad of columns urging the soon-to-be-out-of-a-job man to “step up” and “play for the upset“. Why should the Giants care if the Pats go undefeated? Why should they risk their head trying to sort out somebody else’s (mostly mine, as a Jets fan) problem? If they were playing the Bengals, would anybody be suggesting that Plaxico Burress suit up, let alone see the field?
The only thing that should make any difference to Coughlin, Elisha, Brandon Jacobs, or Jerry Reese is trying to steal the NFC Super Bowl spot. A long shot? Sure. Which is why resting a banged up team the week before going into a very winnable road playoff game (the Giants might suck, but so do the Bucs and ‘Hawks and you know it) is not only the right move, its the only move.
For weeks now we have been told that “this is their Super Bowl”, referring to whatever team was set to line up against Brady that particular Sunday: the Eagles, Ravens, Jets (god bless their souls) and Dolphins all played knowing a win would salvage an otherwise lost season. So despite the normal tendency for a shit team to send out backup offensive lineman and wide receivers to essentially audition for next year, each of these teams got up and tried to knock the Gladiators off their pedestal. Each team gave it its best shot. Each came up short. No coaching decisions questioned there.
But with the Giants, they have something to play for — and it’s not this week. What happens on Saturday makes no difference in the grand scheme of their season. Their “Super Bowl” is the same as every other playoff team’s: the actual Super Bowl. The Giants, and beleaguered Coughlin and Elisha in particular, need to win a playoff game. Plain and simple. Beating the Pats on Saturday would be a great regular season finale, but if it is followed by an early post-season exit, nobody is gonna find solace in a Week 17 upset, and nobody is going to care about Coughlin’s story while he stands in the soup line.
So a memo to Mr. Coughlin: the Pats are none of your business. Coach as if you were playing a 5-10 team, because in the end, nobody that pays your salary really cares about your Week 17 ‘W’ or ‘L’, no matter how many national television networks are simulcasting the game. Rest your troops and prepare for the battle down in Tampa or Seattle: that is where the real war will begin to be waged.
God I wish they could both lose.
whereIstand Tags
- Was the NFL’s punishment of Patriots head coach Bill Belichick appropriate?
- Should Michael Vick be banned from the NFL?
- Are former NFL players sufficiently compensated by the National Football League Players Association for their post-career injuries?
- Should the NFL have rules limiting end-zone celebrations?
- Will Michael Vick be able to successfully return to the NFL?
- Is Adrian Peterson the best running back in the NFL?
- Should the NFL reinstate Pacman Jones?
- Should the NFL eliminate preseason games?
- Should the NFL reinstate Ricky Williams?
- Should the NFL expand its regular season beyond 16 games?
- Who is the best offensive player in the NFL?
- Who will win the NFC East?
- Will the New England Patriots win the Super Bowl?
- Who will win the AFC East?
- Will the New England Patriots go undefeated during the 2007 regular-season?
- What effect will Randy Moss’ acquisition have on the New England Patriots?
- Are the 2007 New England Patriots the best football team of all time?
We all know about how much money schools and football programs stand to make if their team receives a Bowl bid, or better yet, a BCS Bowl bid, but what do the players get?
George Mitchell could be Peter Gammons’ paternal grandfather…seriously, in the history of narcs ruining everybody else’s fun, has one ever looked so sinister and cold as GM? Forget that, has any audible human ever looked so close to death? Try some V8, Mr. Mitchell, it might bring back the color to your otherwise lifeless body.